In response to COVID-19 vaccines becoming more widely available to the general public, the New Jersey Department of Labor (NJDOL) issued new guidance on its website in the form of frequently asked questions (FAQ) regarding whether employers can mandate that employees obtain vaccinations as a term and condition of employment.
The newly issued FAQ largely echoes existing federal guidance related to various equal employment opportunity laws such as the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Rehabilitation Act, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, including the Pregnancy Discrimination Act. Specifically, similar to other federal requirements, the guidance makes clear that New Jersey employers may mandate that their employees be vaccinated against COVID-19 as long as the employer engages in an interactive process with employees to determine whether they may be exempt from the requirement as a result of a disability or “a sincerely held religious belief, practice, or observance.” The NJDOL also adds a specific ground for an exemption if an employee’s “doctor has advised them not to get the vaccine while pregnant or breastfeeding.”
If an employee presents verification of their need to be exempted from vaccination, the employee may be offered a reasonable accommodation. The FAQ lists several forms of these such as “allowing the employee to continue to work remotely, or otherwise to work in a manner that would reduce or eliminate the risk of harm to other employees or to the public” or “providing the employee with personal protective equipment that sufficiently mitigates the employee’s risk of COVID-19 transmission and exposure.”
Going forward, New Jersey employers should take steps to develop or revise internal procedures and policies to incorporate this guidance by providing a procedure for dialogue with employees to determine the employee’s specific issue and explore potential reasonable accommodations that could overcome any limitation. Employers should encourage employees to suggest specific reasonable accommodations that they believe would allow them to perform their jobs without compromising health and safety in the workplace as a result of not receiving the COVID-19 vaccination. Employers should make clear in their policies, however, that they are not required to provide any specific employee-requested accommodation and may provide an alternative modification to the extent it can be made without imposing an undue hardship on the employer. Such policies should also stress that the employer will make determinations about reasonable accommodations on a case-by-case basis considering various factors based on an individualized assessment in each situation.
The guidance further provides that “if there is no reasonable accommodation that an employer can provide that would mitigate the risk of COVID-19 transmission to its employees and customers, then an employer can enforce its policy of excluding unvaccinated employees from the physical workplace, even if the condition is due to disability, pregnancy or breastfeeding, or a sincerely held religious belief and that such exclusion is deemed lawful under the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination. The NJDOL cautions, however, that such circumstances do “not mean that an employer can automatically discipline an employee if they cannot get vaccinated, as the employer may be precluded from doing so by other laws, regulations or policies.” Indeed, analysis of state and local law is vital when employers are deciding whether to require vaccinations as nearly all states and the District of Columbia have some form of presently pending or recently enacted legislation related to allowing or prohibiting employer-mandated COVID-19 vaccinations.
In sum, although a requirement that employees be vaccinated against COVID-19 may be lawful in certain circumstances, the current regulatory guidance suggests that employers institute voluntary vaccination policies rather than forcing employees to be vaccinated. Additionally, the NJDOL states that “[f]or employers with a unionized workforce,” such as those in the construction industry, “the applicable collective bargaining agreement already may vest the employer with the management right to unilaterally develop and implement a vaccine program.” As the lawfulness of employer-mandated vaccinations may implicate multiple federal, state and local laws, as well as other existing policies and agreements, employers are encouraged to consult with qualified counsel knowledgeable in this area of law before adopting a vaccination policy in the workplace.
If you have any questions, please feel free to reach out via email to Aaron C. Schlesinger, Esq. at firstname.lastname@example.org or Lauren Rayner Davis, Esq. at email@example.com or by phone at (201) 343-3434.